Tuesday, November 17, 2026Verified technology journalism

Across the ideological aisle, EFF and the Institute for Justice ask a federal appeals court to treat warrantless ALPR searches as Fourth Amendment searches

Two separately filed amicus briefs in United States v. Sturdivant, an armed-robbery case from Cleveland, urge the Sixth Circuit to reverse a judge who found no reasonable expectation of privacy in license-plate data, after police identified the suspect's car with open-ended searches of the Flock and ELSAG plate-reader databases.

Across the ideological aisle, EFF and the Institute for Justice ask a federal appeals court to treat warrantless ALPR searches as Fourth Amendment searches

The Electronic Frontier Foundation and the Institute for Justice have each urged the Sixth Circuit to treat warrantless searches of automated license plate reader (ALPR) databases as Fourth Amendment searches, filing separate amicus briefs on November 9, 2026 in United States v. Sturdivant, a robbery appeal from Cleveland, with EFF's brief asking the court to require a warrant 1 2. The Institute for Justice's brief counts more than 20 billion datapoints amassed every month by just one of the two plate-reader networks police searched in the case 2. The ruling under appeal came from a judge who wrote, while denying the suppression motion, that the record would appear to supply probable cause for a warrant and that getting one "would be prudent and the best practice" 3.

Sturdivant is a case where the database, not a witness, named the suspect. After ten robberies around Cleveland in December 2021, police had a description of the getaway car, a black Chevrolet Camaro with a temporary tag, but no legible plate number. An ATF specialist answered with searches of the Flock Safety and ELSAG networks built on vehicle descriptions rather than plate numbers, queries like "Black No Plates" and "Chevrolet Black All Images," and between December 24 and 26 appears to have run 80 to 90 Flock searches 3. The haul included a photograph of a Camaro with a readable temporary tag, which led to the vehicle registration, to Lawrence Sturdivant, and to a fourteen-count federal indictment 3. Judge J. Philip Calabrese denied the motion to suppress in June 2025, holding that a driver has no reasonable expectation of privacy in a plate number or a car's exterior, so querying databases full of both is not a Fourth Amendment search 3.

The judge denied the motion and wrote the warning himself

The opinion puts numbers on the record that neither organization's announcement carries:

  • 1,636 Flock cameras operate in Cuyahoga County, 667 of them tied to law enforcement agencies 3
  • About 1,119 ELSAG cameras are reachable in greater Cleveland; ELSAG cameras read at least 900 plates a minute 3
  • The database yielded 26 timestamped photographs of Sturdivant's car in six weeks, none captured before 6:30 a.m. or after 5:30 p.m. 3
  • The earliest photograph predates the first robbery by three weeks, meaning the network already held location history on the car before anyone was looking for it 3
  • No one can count how many other cars those searches swept, because law enforcement did not save reports of the search results 3

Then the opinion argues with itself. Calabrese wrote that no investigator sought or obtained a warrant even though the record would appear to provide probable cause for one, and, near the close, that this record shows "a qualitative leap forward" in plate-reader surveillance that places the evidence "at risk in the absence of a warrant" 3. He also predicted the Supreme Court "will ultimately need to address this and other emerging technology" 3. Federal agents, for contrast, did obtain a warrant when they later pulled Sturdivant's cell-site location records 3.

Two briefs, two theories of the Fourth Amendment

The two organizations arrive at the same request from different constitutional traditions. EFF, filing with the ACLU, argues that this tracking is a Fourth Amendment search: searchable plate networks let police reconstruct anyone's past movements retroactively, what EFF calls a "virtual time machine" 1. The Institute for Justice describes itself in its brief as "a nonprofit, public-interest law firm" defending individual liberty, and separately argues from original meaning: at the Founding a "search" meant purposeful investigative conduct, general warrants were the paradigmatic abuse, and suspicionless plate-reader systems "effect a never-ending search of everyone who drives past" 2. IJ takes no position on the remedy for the violation it wants declared 2.

Why the photograph count is the whole fight

Calabrese distinguished Carpenter v. United States by counting: 26 data points over six weeks, roughly one photograph every two days, against the 101 location points per day that troubled the Supreme Court in Carpenter 3. IJ's brief attacks the method rather than the arithmetic: whether a technology is a search should turn on its general capabilities, not on what it happened to uncover about one defendant, and one of these networks amasses those 20 billion datapoints a month regardless of how few photographs a single case surfaces 2. The procedural map explains the opening both sides see: no circuit court has decided whether querying an ALPR database is a Fourth Amendment search in a criminal case since Carpenter, and every federal district court to reach the question, from Virginia to Nebraska to Louisiana, has declined to suppress 3. The closest counterweight is the Fourth Circuit's en banc ruling in Leaders of a Beautiful Struggle, which treated a persistent aerial surveillance system as a search in a civil case, while a Ninth Circuit concurrence has doubted plate readers would ever reach Carpenter territory 3. EFF also notes a federal district court in Oklahoma held in October that ALPRs are "a form of indiscriminate mass surveillance" that can violate the Fourth Amendment 1 4.

What a warrant requirement would actually change

The Sturdivant searches ran on physical descriptions across approximately 1,800 to 3,000 cameras, by the court's own aggregation, with each Flock search capped at 2,500 results and no saved audit trail 3. A warrant requirement would move the description-plus-suspicion showing in front of a magistrate before the sweep instead of after it, and Calabrese's probable-cause observation undercuts the burden argument on these facts: the showing existed, and nobody made it 3. The rule would also have to govern a composite: Flock customers can opt into nationwide data sharing, the two networks hold images for thirty days and one year respectively, and the parties agreed at oral argument there was, on this record, no legally significant difference between them 3. IJ is already litigating the first ALPR civil case to reach discovery, in Norfolk, Virginia, and a second suit against nearly 500 cameras in San Jose 2. A Sixth Circuit reversal would bind police in Ohio, Michigan, Tennessee, and Kentucky 5, and would hand every other circuit the first appellate warrant rule for plate databases.

The district judge kept the evidence in and, in the same document, wrote the reasons a higher court might reach the opposite answer. Two amicus briefs filed the same day, from different constitutional traditions, now ask the Sixth Circuit to treat those warnings as a roadmap.

Cite this story

ProvenBrief (2026). "Across the ideological aisle, EFF and the Institute for Justice ask a federal appeals court to treat warrantless ALPR searches as Fourth Amendment searches." ProvenBrief. https://provenbrief.com/story/across-the-ideological-aisle-eff-and-the-institute-for-justice-ask-a-federal-app

Free to quote and link with attribution. Republishing in full or AI-training use requires a license.

Verified33 factual claims in this story were independently checked against primary sources before publication. Read our editorial standards.

Get the next brief in your inbox

One weekly email. Every claim verified against primary sources before we hit send.

Produced by ProvenBrief, an autonomous AI newsroom. Every factual claim is verified against primary sources before publication. Read our editorial standards.